Football has a problem. -Protecting Young People from Negative Influence

We live in a world where influence has become increasingly powerful and difficult to recognise.

Advertising, political messaging, social media and artificial intelligence can all shape what people believe, fear and value. History has shown that whole populations can gradually accept ideas and behaviours that clearly offend basic morality. This does not usually happen because everyone suddenly becomes a bad person. It happens slowly, through repetition, group pressure, fear, loyalty and the normalisation of behaviour that would once have been rejected.

This raises an important question for anyone who works with young people:

How can we help them develop the judgement and character needed to resist negative influences?

For me, sport provides one of the best opportunities.

Sport Is More Than a Game

A sporting environment can teach young people about discipline, honesty, responsibility, teamwork, courage and respect. It can give them a sense of belonging and introduce them to adults who model positive behaviour.

However, sport does not automatically produce good character.

The values young people learn depend on the environment created by coaches, officials, administrators, parents and senior athletes. Sport can teach cooperation and fairness, but it can also teach cheating, intimidation, aggression and the belief that winning excuses almost anything.

This is why coaches carry such an important responsibility.

Young athletes notice what adults tolerate. They notice whether talented players receive special treatment. They notice whether cheating is punished or quietly admired. They notice how coaches behave toward officials, opponents and weaker members of the team.

Values are not taught only through speeches or posters. They are taught through what happens every day.

The Example of Professional Football

Football is the most influential sport in much of the world. Its leading players are watched and copied by millions of young people. Unfortunately, the behaviour permitted in professional football does not always provide the example that sport should offer.

Players frequently argue aggressively with referees, surround match officials, exaggerate contact, pretend to be injured and attempt to deceive officials to gain an advantage. Tactical fouls are often treated as clever rather than dishonest. Coaches, commentators and supporters may excuse unacceptable behaviour when it benefits their own team.

This creates a troubling message:

Dishonesty is acceptable when it helps us win.

Young players see highly paid professionals rewarded despite behaving in ways that would not be accepted in many other areas of life. They may then imitate the same conduct in school, community competitions and junior sport.

The influence extends beyond the players.

Supporters often adopt the language and behaviour they see around the professional game. Abuse of referees, hostility toward opposing supporters and blind defence of one’s own team can become normal. Loyalty to a club may become more important than fairness, evidence or moral consistency.

This reflects a wider problem in society. People often judge conduct according to who is doing it. When the opposition behaves badly, it is condemned. When our own side behaves in the same way, it is explained, minimised or justified.

A useful moral test is:

What would I think of this behaviour if the opposing side were doing it?

That question applies equally to sport, politics and public life.

Creating a Protective Sporting Environment

My motivation as a coach is not simply to teach young people how to play a sport. It is to help create an environment that protects them from some of the negative influences they will face in the future.

That environment should teach young people that:

  • strength includes self-control;
  • success does not excuse dishonesty;
  • opponents deserve respect;
  • officials should not be abused;
  • teammates have responsibilities to one another;
  • mistakes are opportunities to learn;
  • leadership means protecting those with less power;
  • courage sometimes means refusing to follow the crowd.

Young people should also understand that their value is not determined only by sporting performance. An athlete who believes that personal worth depends entirely on winning, popularity or approval may become easier to manipulate.

A healthy sports program gives young people a secure identity, trusted relationships and opportunities to practise making good decisions.

Coaches can support this by responding consistently to bullying, cheating, aggression and disrespect. Talented players must be held to the same standards as everyone else. Winning should never become more important than the wellbeing and character of the participants.

One simple question can guide the culture of a team:

Is this action fair, truthful, respectful and safe for everyone involved?

Asked regularly, this question can help moral judgement become a habit.

The Responsibility of Sport

Sport has enormous cultural influence. It can unite communities, create friendships and give young people purpose. But its positive influence cannot be taken for granted.

When professional sport tolerates deception, intimidation and abuse, those behaviours spread through the people who watch and copy it. When community sport deliberately reinforces honesty, respect and responsibility, it can provide young people with a defence against manipulation and negative social pressure.

We may not be able to control every influence that reaches young people. We can, however, create environments in which they feel secure, valued and encouraged to think for themselves.

A coach may never know how many poor decisions have been prevented by a positive sporting culture. But by modelling consistency, fairness and genuine care, a coach can become one of the strongest protective influences in a young person’s life.

The true value of sport should not be measured only by trophies, scores or championships. It should also be measured by the kind of people it helps to develop.

Leave a comment